The UK government has lost its attempt to keep secret an order demanding access to encrypted Apple customer data, after a tribunal ruled that acknowledging the order would not damage national security. The decision represents a significant development in Apple’s long-running dispute with the Home Office over iCloud encryption and could allow more of the legal battle to take place publicly.
The Investigatory Powers Tribunal rejected the government’s argument that it should be permitted to neither confirm nor deny the existence of a technical capability notice issued to Apple.
According to the tribunal’s ruling, widespread reporting about the demand, along with discussions involving British and American officials, had already brought substantial details of the dispute into the public domain.
The government had argued that formally confirming the existence of the order could undermine national security. However, the tribunal found insufficient evidence that acknowledging it would cause the claimed harm.
The decision follows months of legal proceedings and international scrutiny over the government’s attempts to obtain access to encrypted customer information.
The dispute centers on a technical capability notice issued under the UK’s Investigatory Powers Act, which allows the government to require technology companies to provide certain capabilities to assist law enforcement and intelligence agencies.
Apple has consistently opposed demands that would weaken the encryption protecting its customers’ information.
In February 2025, Apple stopped offering Advanced Data Protection to new users in the United Kingdom following the dispute.
Advanced Data Protection provides end-to-end encryption for additional categories of iCloud information, including backups, photos and notes, meaning that not even Apple can access the protected data.
The UK government’s demands have attracted criticism from privacy campaigners and American officials concerned about the potential consequences of weakening encryption.
The dispute has also raised questions about whether government requirements imposed in one country could have implications for customers elsewhere.
The tribunal’s decision concerns whether the government’s order can remain secret. It does not determine whether the underlying demand is lawful or whether Apple must comply with it.
Apple’s legal challenge can continue with greater public scrutiny, although sensitive details may still be considered privately.
The case is particularly significant for UK Apple customers, who have been unable to newly enable Advanced Data Protection since Apple withdrew the feature in the country.
There has been no announcement that Advanced Data Protection will become available again to new UK users following the ruling.
The tribunal’s decision nevertheless represents an important step toward greater transparency about the government’s demands and the potential implications for Apple’s encrypted services.