Apple HomeView owners criticize buggy Siri AI as basic commands fail

Apple’s new HomeView smart display is facing criticism just days after launch, with early owners reporting that Siri AI struggles to perform basic tasks including setting timers, controlling music and responding to voice commands, leaving some customers describing the software as unfinished.

The $299 smart home device went on sale on November 13, but discussions on MacRumors forums and Reddit have since highlighted recurring Siri failures. Some users say their HomeView refuses to create timers or alarms, claiming it needs a software update even when the device shows the latest version is installed.

Others report Siri taking unusually long to respond, repeatedly announcing that it is downloading, or recognizing a request without carrying it out. Macworld documented complaints covering Siri, Apple Music, Photos, setup and automatic display brightness, while MacRumors reported multiple forum discussions involving frustrated owners.

The timer problems are especially frustrating given HomeView’s emphasis on kitchen use. Apple promotes the display as a convenient way to follow recipes and manage cooking timers without reaching for an iPhone. As we explored in our look at HomeView’s cooking features, hands-free assistance is a central part of the device’s appeal.

HomeView owners report Siri and Apple Music problems

Music playback has emerged as another repeated complaint. Users describe Siri failing to pause or resume songs, refusing to adjust volume, and sending commands to a paired iPhone instead of HomeView, despite the assistant visibly listening on the smart display. In households with several Apple devices, some say playback occasionally begins in the wrong room.

Additional reports describe Photos not opening as expected, widgets losing preferences, inconsistent auto-brightness and unsuccessful device setup. These reports come from individual owners and do not establish how widespread the problems are across all HomeView units, but they suggest the complaints extend beyond a single Siri feature.

Some users have begun questioning whether HomeView was ready to launch. In a Reddit discussion about returning the device, one owner described repeatedly having to ask Siri to stop a timer, despite already using numerous Apple Home accessories and HomePods. Other owners have reported similar frustrations, while praising HomeView’s screen, speakers and physical design.

Not everyone is experiencing these issues. Several owners say Siri works reliably on their units, and some have resolved timer or music problems by restarting HomeView, the paired iPhone or both. One MacRumors forum user said a full iPhone restart restored timer and Apple Music commands after the HomeView insisted a newer software version was needed.

Apple is already planning a Siri AI update for HomeView

Apple has acknowledged a separate Siri AI limitation involving smart locks and garage doors. During early reviews, Siri sometimes claimed HomeView did not have a camera, preventing recognized household members from unlocking compatible accessories by voice. The company has said it plans to address that behavior in a December software update, as The Apple Post previously reported.

There is no confirmation that the upcoming update will also fix the newly reported timer, music or setup problems. Apple released HomeView Software 27.2 ahead of launch, but affected users say the issues can persist even when their devices show that software as up to date.

Siri AI is currently labeled as a beta experience on HomeView, and certain personal features depend on a nearby compatible iPhone or iPad. That may help explain why some commands behave differently depending on the household member or paired device, although Apple has not identified a single cause for the reported failures.

The early criticism contrasts with the generally positive response to HomeView’s hardware. In our HomeView review, we highlighted the usefulness of a dedicated Apple Home touchscreen while noting concerns about slower Siri requests, software limitations and privacy.

At $299 in the United States and £299 in the United Kingdom, HomeView is intended to make everyday household tasks easier. For customers unable to set a simple timer or control Apple Music reliably, that promise is not yet being consistently delivered. Whether Apple can resolve the complaints with software updates will be an important test of the new device’s first few months.

Share
Published by
David Joseppi